“The Man with the Hoe” was a powerful protest poem written by Edwin Markham in 1899. It denounces the exploitation of workers by the wealthy ruling class and highlights the suffering of workers in a capitalist, profit-driven society. Jean-François Millet’s painting The Man with the Hoe served as the inspiration for the widely read poem, which came to symbolize the struggle of the working class. Markham emphasizes the psychological and physical costs of labor while urging the ruling class to consider their actions and the moral consequences of abusing others.

Introduction to the Poem’s Theme

The notion that humans were created in the image of God is covered in the first section of the poem. According to Markham, the Bible’s Book of Genesis suggests that all humans were created in God’s likeness. However, the poem’s portrayal of suffering contrasts sharply with this initial passage. By using this contrast, Markham asks readers: if humans are created in God’s image, how has this guy become so debased?

A laborer who has been physically warped, twisted, and broken by centuries of work is the poem’s protagonist. His body is a representation of how generations of people have been forced into hard labor by the demands of a profit-driven society. Markham claims that this man and hundreds of others like him have been reduced to inert robots by dehumanization and the loss of their individuality, feeling, and dignity. The poem accuses the ruling class of moral failure by exploiting workers for their personal benefit while ignoring their suffering.

The Condition of the Man in the Poem

The poem’s protagonist is a laborer whose appearance and physical characteristics are the result of years of hard labor. His body is slumped, his shoulders are heavy, and his face shows signs of agony and fatigue. This graphic represents the working class’s struggles over centuries of exploitation. Despite providing the resources and food that keep others alive, this laborer is denied happiness, freedom, and hope.

Using the metaphor of a beast of burden, Markham describes this man as “stolid and stunned.” The metaphor claims that workers are forced to work constantly without the ability to dream, be hopeful, or grieve. It is believed that his intelligence has been extinguished by hard labor; his ability to think, to imagine, and to interact with the outside world has been taken away by the necessity of existence.

The working class is abused by capitalism, which enslaves them to endless labor cycles without offering them freedom, dignity, or fair compensation. This image is a critique of capitalism. The man’s suffering is a metaphor for how workers are treated as nothing more than manufacturing tools in systems that put profit before of justice or compassion.

The Role of the Ruling Class in the Exploitation of Workers

Markham shifts his attention to the ruling class in The Man with the Hoe. He addresses them directly, calling them “masters, lords, and rulers in all lands.” In this candid lecture, he questions their moral and societal responsibilities. He contends that these individuals exploit their workers for monetary gain and political power, ignoring the suffering they inflict. In his critique of the greed of the wealthy, Markham argues that their actions have turned workers into “monstrous things” who have lost their humanity, autonomy, and dignity.

The poem criticizes the ruling class for taking advantage of workers’ labor without providing them with a fair share of the wealth they create. Because of this exploitation, the workers’ bodies are warped, their emotions are crushed, and they are left scarred. This poem challenges the wealthy to think about the consequences of their greed. How can they expect heavenly benefits while they oppress and harm others?

The Symbolism of the Man’s Condition

The physical condition of the guy in The guy with the Hoe is a metaphor for larger societal problems. His body is a symbol of generations of workers who were forced to toil without rest or hope. According to Markham, his mangled and broken body is proof that the wealthy abuse workers and are motivated by greed and a lack of moral responsibility.

The poem also suggests that the condition of workers reflects the moral and spiritual failings of society. The laborer, who was once a symbol of God’s creation, is now reduced to a slave and in agony. Since humans were meant to be free, moral, and thinking beings, Markham claims that this transformation amounts to a breach of the original divine order since greed and exploitation have turned people into animals.

The Broader Social and Moral Message

Fundamentally, The Man with the Hoe is about more than simply one worker’s pain. In addition to drawing attention to the historical pain of the working class, Markham’s poem criticizes the capitalist and greedy structures that have produced and sustained this misery. He argues that labor exploitation is a spiritual issue as well as a social one, likening human suffering to moral evil.

Markham depicts the negative effects of ongoing exploitation in a somber manner. He issues a warning that the ruling class would eventually have to “reckon” with the pain of the workers. As workers struggle against their rulers, this reckoning may spark broad opposition and social transformation. According to the poem, unless the ruling class starts to value workers’ dignity and provide them with equality, fairness, and fair treatment, these repercussions will materialize.

Critique of Capitalism and Greed

The capitalist system is harshly criticized in the poem for abusing workers while enabling the wealthy to amass fortune at the expense of others. The worker in the poem is a metaphor for the thousands of people who put in a lot of effort yet remain impoverished because the affluent keep the money they earn from their labor. Markham uses the pain of the worker to show how greed distorts civilizations and leads to inequity.

One of the poem’s most striking lines is “Slave of the wheel of labor.” It highlights how employees are compelled to work nonstop in order to satisfy the expectations of a system that is driven by profit. Even yet, they don’t profit from the riches they contribute to creating. This metaphor emphasizes how economic structures that put money above freedom and human dignity imprison labor.

The Final Question

A series of queries addressed to the ruling class conclude the poem. Markham inquires as to how they plan to make up for the pain they have caused. How are they going to heal the minds, bodies, and souls of the workers they have taken advantage of? How will they defend their behavior, particularly when it comes to judgment? These inquiries highlight the fact that exploitation has both social and spiritual repercussions. Markham cautions that the ruling class cannot continue to overlook their behavior.

A feeling of dread permeates the poem’s conclusion. It implies that the ruling class will not be immune to the repercussions of their exploitation and that workers will rebel to seek justice. In addition to upending society, this uprising will compel an examination of the moral deficiencies that have permitted such misery.

---

Exploitation, avarice, and societal inequity are all sharply criticized in The Man with the Hoe. The poem draws attention to the misery of workers and the ethical shortcomings of capitalism systems by its striking imagery, moral reflection, and direct reference to the ruling class. It challenges readers to consider the repercussions of disregarding greed and injustice and issues a sobering warning: unless anything is done, misery will only worsen and there will eventually be a reckoning.

This poem is still a timeless warning of the perils of unbridled greed as well as the value of equality, justice, and compassion. Edwin Markham challenges readers to think on the moral and spiritual consequences of exploitation by bringing attention to the suffering of the working class.