1. “And so have I addressed me. Fortune now / To my heart’s hope! Gold, silver, and base lead.”
- Explanation: Arragon says he’s ready and now hopes that fortune (luck) will align with what he desires. He then observes the three caskets: gold, silver, and lead.
- Analysis: He invokes fortune, yet ironically, his later speech suggests he trusts merit over luck.
- Themes: Fate vs. choice, appearance vs. reality.
- Technique: Personification of “Fortune” (as a goddess). The word “base” to describe lead is also judgmental language.
2. “Who chooseth me must give and hazard all he hath.”
- Explanation: This is the inscription on the lead casket.
- Analysis: He reads it aloud but dismisses it. The message demands self-sacrifice, something Arragon isn’t prepared for.
- Themes: Love as sacrifice, value and worth.
- Technique: Foreshadowing—this line hints that the correct choice involves selflessness, which Arragon lacks.
3. “You shall look fairer ere I give or hazard.”
- Explanation: He says the box should look more beautiful before he risks everything for it.
- Analysis: He judges by appearances while claiming not to, showing hypocrisy.
- Themes: Appearance vs. reality, materialism.
- Technique: Irony—he rejects what “looks” common but himself is guided by looks.
4. “What says the golden chest? Ha, let me see: ‘Who chooseth me shall gain what many men desire.’”
- Explanation: He reads the inscription on the gold chest.
- Analysis: He considers it but rejects it because it appeals to the majority.
- Themes: Individualism vs. conformity, vanity.
- Technique: Repetition and mockery of the word “many” to show disdain for common judgment.
5. “What many men desire—that ‘many’ may be meant / By the fool multitude that choose by show,”
- Explanation: He interprets “many men” as foolish people who judge by appearances.
- Analysis: Arragon considers himself above the crowd, placing trust in his intellect.
- Themes: Pride, wisdom vs. foolishness.
- Technique: Alliteration (“fool, fool multitude”) emphasizes his scorn.
6. “Not learning more than the fond eye doth teach,”
- Explanation: He criticizes people who rely only on what they see.
- Analysis: He tries to appear deep, yet later we see that he also fails to understand what truly matters.
- Themes: Judgment, true understanding.
- Technique: Personification of the “fond eye”—giving the eye the ability to teach.
7. “Which pries not to th’ interior, but like the martlet / Builds in the weather on the outward wall,”
- Explanation: He compares those who judge by appearances to martlets (birds) that build nests on the outside of walls, vulnerable to bad weather.
- Analysis: He uses an extended metaphor to show that shallow choices are dangerous.
- Themes: Superficiality, vulnerability.
- Technique: Simile & metaphor—comparing humans to birds to mock poor judgment.
8. “Even in the force and road of casualty.”
- Explanation: He says such choices are exposed to chance and misfortune.
- Analysis: He values control and disdains chance, yet this is ironic given that choosing the right casket partly involves luck.
- Themes: Fate, uncertainty.
- Language: “Casualty” here means danger or chance misfortune—archaic usage.
9. “I will not choose what many men desire, / Because I will not jump with common spirits / And rank me with the barbarous multitudes.”
- Explanation: He refuses the gold casket because he does not want to align himself with the masses.
- Analysis: Arragon shows snobbery and arrogance. He values exclusivity and merit.
- Themes: Class, elitism, pride.
- Technique: Metaphor—“jump with common spirits” means to be associated with average people.
10. “Why, then, to thee, thou silver treasure house. / Tell me once more what title thou dost bear.”
- Explanation: He turns to the silver casket, which looks dignified enough for him.
- Analysis: He still judges by external value—silver is a precious metal.
- Themes: Materialism, merit.
- Language: “Treasure house” is a grandiose term—shows his inflated expectations.
11. “‘Who chooseth me shall get as much as he deserves.’”
- Explanation: This is the inscription on the silver casket.
- Analysis: He is attracted to this message because he believes he deserves a lot.
- Themes: Deserving vs. entitlement, self-worth.
- Technique: The line invites introspection, but Arragon’s arrogance blinds him to its deeper meaning.
“And well said, too…” to “…my fortunes here.”
Lines & Explanation:
“And well said, too; for who shall go about / To cozen fortune and be honorable / Without the stamp of merit?”
→ Arragon agrees with the inscription—only the deserving should win. He mocks those who try to cheat fate and attain honor without earning it.
- Language technique: Rhetorical question, metaphor (“stamp of merit”)
- Theme: Justice, merit vs. appearance, honor
“Let none presume / To wear an undeservèd dignity.”
→ He insists that no one should take a high position they don’t deserve.
- Technique: Alliteration (“deserved dignity”), declarative tone
- Theme: Deserving vs. social status
“O, that estates, degrees, and offices / Were not derived corruptly…”
→ He laments how wealth and power are often obtained through corruption, not merit.
- Theme: Corruption, inequality, social critique
“How many then should cover that stand bare?”
→ If only merit mattered, many poor but worthy people would gain respect.
- Language: Contrast (“cover” vs “bare”)
- Theme: Appearances vs. reality
“How much low peasantry would then be gleaned / From the true seed of honor?”
→ True noble qualities might be found in the common people, not just the elite.
- Imagery: Agricultural metaphor (“seed of honor”)
- Theme: Class structure, virtue in disguise
“Well, but to my choice.”
→ He cuts his own philosophical rambling to get back to business.
“Who chooseth me shall get as much as he deserves.”
→ He believes he deserves a great reward—he assumes he’s worthy.
- Irony: He assumes he deserves much but ends up humiliated.
- Theme: Self-deception, Pride
🔓 Lines: “He opens the silver casket…” to “Is that my prize?”
“Too long a pause for that which you find there.” – Portia mocks his hesitation before opening the casket—there’s nothing good inside.
“What’s here? The portrait of a blinking idiot…” – Arragon is stunned and humiliated. He finds an image of a fool instead of Portia.
- Symbolism: The fool represents Arragon’s pride and folly.
- Theme: Appearance vs. reality, humbling of arrogance
“Did I deserve no more than a fool’s head?”
→ He’s incredulous—he thought he deserved more.
- Irony: He gets exactly what the inscription promised—what he deserves.
- Theme: Misjudgment, pride, self-worth
🔥 Riddle inside the casket:
“The fire seven times tried this…”
→ Refers to the idea that true judgment is tested through trials, like gold refined in fire.
- Biblical allusion: Psalm 12:6 – “tried in a furnace of earth, purified seven times.”
- Theme: Wisdom through testing, virtue under pressure
“Some there be that shadows kiss; / Such have but a shadow’s bliss.”
→ Those who fall for appearances only find illusions, not true happiness.
- Language: Contrast between “shadows” (illusions) and “bliss” (real happiness)
- Theme: Deceptive appearances, folly of shallow judgment
“There be fools alive, iwis, / Silvered o’er—and so was this.”
→ Many fools look wise because they’re “coated” in silver—like this casket.
- Metaphor: Silver is superficial beauty; the fool inside shows true worth.
- Theme: Value vs. appearance, surface deception
“So begone; you are sped.”
→ You’ve been dismissed, and quickly.
“With one fool’s head I came to woo, / But I go away with two.”
→ Witty self-deprecation—he leaves with the image of a fool and feels like one too.
- Pun: “Two fools’ heads”—literal (the image) and metaphorical (his own foolishness)
- Theme: Consequences of arrogance, poetic justice
🔥 Portia and Nerissa’s Reactions:
PORTIA: “Thus hath the candle singed the moth.”
→ Like a moth drawn to a flame, Arragon’s pride led him to his downfall.
- Metaphor: Classical symbol of self-destructive desire
- Theme: Hubris, fate, illusion
NERISSA: “Hanging and wiving goes by destiny.”
→ A witty proverb: both marriage and execution are matters of fate.
- Theme: Fate vs. free will, destiny in love
💌 Closing: Bassanio’s Arrival
MESSENGER: “A young Venetian… comes before / To signify th’ approaching of his lord.”
→ Excitement builds. Bassanio’s arrival is poetic—he’s described like spring bringing summer.
- Imagery & metaphor: “A day in April” suggests hope and beauty.
- Theme: Love, anticipation, destiny
PORTIA: “Quick Cupid’s post that comes so mannerly.”
→ Portia is hopeful—it might be Bassanio, the man she truly loves.
Leave a Reply