Women in Flames as Life-Givers, and Men as Agents of Death and Destruction
Robbie Arnott’s Flames is a symbolically complex tale that delves into issues of life, death, and nature. One of the novel’s most striking characteristics is how women are frequently depicted as life-giving powers, whilst males are connected with death and devastation.
While this distinction is visible in many ways, Arnott also offers complications, demonstrating how life and death are intertwined and not only determined by gender. This essay will look at the roles of women and men in the novel, utilizing evidence to illustrate these themes and how they disrupt established gender stereotypes.
Women as Life-Giving Forces
The women in Flames are frequently shown as caring, resilient, and inextricably linked to life in both real and metaphorical ways. Their roles emphasize development, rebirth, and emotional power, in contrast to the masculine characters’ destructive impulses.
One of the most obvious instances is Edith McAllister, Levi and Charlotte’s mother. Edith’s death and subsequent reincarnation demonstrate her link to life beyond death. She is one of several women in the McAllister family who, rather than dying, are “reborn into other forms of life.”
Levi characterizes the occurrence by saying, “She didn’t die; she became something else.” Edith’s rebirth symbolizes the cycle of life and death, stressing women’s perseverance and life-giving qualities. Her homecoming, however, causes stress among her children, particularly Levi, who is struggling to make sense of it. Edith’s narrative demonstrates how women in the novel have the ability to connect life and death, resulting in rebirth and continuance.
Charlotte, Edith’s daughter, is another outstanding example of a life giver. She acts as a protective and calming force, especially for her brother Levi. Charlotte’s maternal personality is seen in how she gives emotional support, despite Levi’s activities causing tension between them.
Despite their disagreements, she maintains a great affection for him, saying, “Levi and I have never understood each other, but he’s my brother, and I love him.” Her power is also evident in her relationship with Nicola, where she opens herself to love and connection, representing life and development.
Karl’s daughter, Nicola, similarly embodies life-giving traits. Despite Karl’s loss and tribulations, Nicola gives hope into his life. Arnott characterizes her connection with Karl as one characterized by love and warmth: “Nothing could match the blaze of love in her father’s smile.” Nicola’s presence helps Karl negotiate his anguish, demonstrating how women in the novel frequently serve as healers, providing emotional rebirth to people around them.
The novel’s use of water symbolism emphasizes women’s life-giving roles. Water exists in numerous forms, including rivers, lakes, and rain, each with its own significance. Rivers link many sections of the natural world, representing unity and movement. Lakes, such as Crater Lake, signify serenity and consolation, whereas rain near the novel’s end represents rejuvenation and the removal of old tensions. This relationship between water and rebirth reflects the roles of the female characters, who offer healing and progress to the plot.
Men as Agents of Death and Destruction
In contrast to the women’s life-giving traits, the male characters in Flames are frequently linked with destruction, death, and disturbance. This is shown in their behaviors, feelings, and the influence they have on others.
Levi McAllister, Edith’s son, personifies this concept via his fixation with death. Levi’s choice to build a coffin for Charlotte demonstrates his obsession with mortality and inability to deal with grief in a healthy way. His actions cause conflict between him and Charlotte, putting a rift in their relationship.
Charlotte notices his destructive habits and remarks, “Levi’s always been like this, obsessed with things that don’t make sense to anyone else.” Levi’s emphasis on mortality contrasts dramatically with Charlotte’s caring role in the story, illustrating the variations in how men and women deal to loss.
Jack McAllister, the brothers’ father, represents both devastation and emotional distance. Following Edith’s death, Jack removes himself from his children, leaving them to deal on their own. He focuses on his connection with Levi, recognizing a “unbridgeable gap” between them.
His absence leaves a void in Levi and Charlotte’s lives, exacerbating their anguish. Jack’s status as a deity links him even more to destruction, as he witnesses the environmental harm caused by colonization. He observes the arrival of the colonists, describing them as “loud, pale apes” who bring “foul industries” to Tasmania. Jack’s distant manner and perspectives on human ruin highlight the novel’s darkest side of masculinity.
Karl, Nicola’s father, is another masculine figure who represents death and devastation. Karl’s sadness following the loss of his seal consumes him, prompting him to stop tuna hunting, which he formerly saw as his mission. He muses on the evil he has done, adding, “I can’t unsee the blood, the mountains of it.” Karl’s shame and resolve to quit his harmful lifestyle demonstrate how he deals with his previous acts, resulting in a more multifaceted representation of masculinity.
The work also links the subject of devastation to colonialism, which is mostly carried out by men. The South Esk deity considers the consequences of colonization, explaining how the land was damaged by the entrance of the colonisers. He writes: “They hunted the First People in their own homeland, turning paradise into something unrecognizable.” Arnott uses this perspective to attack men’s historical roles in Tasmania’s colonial history, tying masculinity to violence and exploitation.
Complexity and Gender Roles
While Flames frequently identifies women with life and men with death, Arnott complicates these images by demonstrating that life and death are inextricably linked and not solely gender-based. Women in the story also deal with themes of loss and devastation, although males display the ability to develop and heal.
Edith McAllister’s rebirth, while a symbol of perseverance, causes strife and instability in her children’s lives. Her homecoming causes Levi and Charlotte to confront their loss in unique ways, demonstrating how even life-giving energies may cause disturbance. Similarly, Charlotte’s protective attitude does not keep her from feeling loss or suffering. Her journey is punctuated by periods of difficulty and vulnerability, revealing the depths of her personality.
Despite their involvement with destruction, the masculine characters demonstrate periods of redemption and emotional growth. Karl’s choice to forsake tuna hunting indicates his desire for change and a more serene life. Similarly, Levi’s love for Charlotte, despite his actions, displays his fragility and need for connection. Even Jack, despite his detached demeanor, muses on the beauty of nature and the devastation perpetrated by humans, demonstrating his understanding of life’s vulnerability.
In Flames, Robbie Arnott contrasts women’s life-giving responsibilities with men’s destructive impulses, resulting in a fascinating investigation of gender and its relationship to life and death. Women such as Edith, Charlotte, and Nicola represent resilience, rejuvenation, and emotional strength, whereas men like Levi, Jack, and Karl deal with death, devastation, and guilt.
However, Arnott’s portrayal is everything but one-dimensional. He questions established gender norms by highlighting the interconnection of life and death. Finally, Flames asks readers to consider the balance of creation and destruction, reminding them that both are necessary components of the human experience.
Leave a Reply