128,518 hits

Macbeth Act 4 Scene 2 Line-by-Line Explanation

Enter Macduffโ€™s Wife, her Son, and Ross.

LADY MACDUFF

“What had he done to make him fly the land?”

  • Explanation: Lady Macduff questions why her husband fled Scotland. She wonders if he is guilty of something that forced him to leave.
  • Analysis: She assumes people only flee when they are guilty, implying that Macduffโ€™s actions make him look like a traitor.
  • Language Device: Rhetorical Question โ€“ She doesnโ€™t expect an answer but expresses disbelief and frustration.

ROSS

“You must have patience, madam.”

  • Explanation: Ross tells Lady Macduff to be patient and not judge Macduff too quickly.
  • Analysis: He suggests that there may be a reason for Macduffโ€™s actions, hinting at Scotlandโ€™s dangerous political climate.

LADY MACDUFF

“He had none.”

  • Explanation: She argues that Macduff himself lacked patience because he left in a hurry.

**”His flight was madness. When our actions do not,

Our fears do make us traitors.”**

  • Explanation: She believes Macduffโ€™s fear made him act irrationally, making him look guilty even if he isnโ€™t.
  • Analysis: She suggests that even if someone does nothing wrong, running away can make them seem like a traitor.
  • Language Device: Paradox โ€“ People can become traitors by doing nothing, simply because of fear.

ROSS

**”You know not

Whether it was his wisdom or his fear.”**

  • Explanation: Ross tries to calm Lady Macduff, saying Macduff may have left out of wisdom, not fear.
  • Analysis: He suggests that fleeing might have been the best decision in the situation.
  • Language Device: Juxtaposition โ€“ The contrast between wisdom vs. fear highlights how Macduffโ€™s actions are open to interpretation.

LADY MACDUFF

**”Wisdom? To leave his wife, to leave his babes,

His mansion and his titles in a place
From whence himself does fly?”**

  • Explanation: She sarcastically questions whether leaving his family, home, and status behind is truly wise.
  • Analysis: She sees his departure as selfish and unwise, making no sense if Scotland is truly dangerous.
  • Language Device: Repetition (“to leave”) โ€“ Emphasizes abandonment and her growing frustration.

**”He loves us not;

He wants the natural touch; for the poor wren,
The most diminutive of birds, will fight,
Her young ones in her nest, against the owl.”**

  • Explanation: She claims Macduff does not love them, comparing him to a wren (small bird) who refuses to protect its chicks from an owl (danger).
  • Analysis: She suggests that even the weakest creatures protect their young, but Macduff failed as a husband and father.
  • Language Device: Metaphor โ€“ Macduff is the wren abandoning his children, while Macbethโ€™s men are the owl, symbolizing danger.

**”All is the fear, and nothing is the love,

As little is the wisdom, where the flight
So runs against all reason.”**

  • Explanation: She believes Macduff fled out of fear, not love or wisdom.
  • Analysis: She sees his decision as illogical, putting his family in danger instead of protecting them.
  • Language Device: Triadic Structure (Rule of Three) โ€“ “fear, love, wisdom” highlights her anger and disbelief.

ROSS

**”My dearest coz,

I pray you school yourself.”**

  • Explanation: Ross affectionately calls her “coz” (short for cousin, a term for close relatives) and advises her to calm down.
  • Analysis: He understands her pain but believes Macduff had no choice.

**”But for your husband,

He is noble, wise, judicious, and best knows
The fits oโ€™ thโ€™ season.”**

  • Explanation: Ross defends Macduff, calling him noble and wise and saying he understands the political dangers of the time.
  • Analysis: He suggests Macduff left to protect himself and possibly his family, though Lady Macduff does not see it that way.
  • Language Device: Euphemism (“fits oโ€™ thโ€™ season”) โ€“ Refers to Scotlandโ€™s chaotic, violent state without directly mentioning it.

**”I dare not speak much further;

But cruel are the times when we are traitors
And do not know ourselves;”**

  • Explanation: Ross hesitates because speaking openly is dangerous. He reflects on how, in these times, people can be seen as traitors even when they are innocent.
  • Analysis: Macbethโ€™s rule has created paranoia and confusion in Scotland.
  • Language Device: Paradox โ€“ People are considered traitors without knowing why.

**”When we hold rumor

From what we fear, yet know not what we fear,
But float upon a wild and violent sea
Each way and moveโ€””**

  • Explanation: People believe rumors because of fear, even though they donโ€™t fully understand what they are afraid of.
  • Analysis: Ross describes Scotland as unstable and chaotic.
  • Language Device: Metaphor โ€“ Scotland is a “wild and violent sea,” symbolizing its dangerous and unpredictable state.

**”I take my leave of you.

Shall not be long but Iโ€™ll be here again.
Things at the worst will cease or else climb upward
To what they were before.”**

  • Explanation: Ross says goodbye, promising to return soon and expressing hope that things will either end or improve.
  • Analysis: His words are vague and uncertain, reflecting the fearful atmosphere of Scotland.
  • Language Device: Optimistic paradox โ€“ Either things will get worse and collapse or recover, but it is unclear which will happen.

**”โ€”My pretty cousin,

Blessing upon you.”**

  • Explanation: Ross says a warm farewell to Lady Macduff.
  • Analysis: Dramatic Irony โ€“ The audience knows she is about to be murdered, making Rossโ€™s blessing tragically futile.

LADY MACDUFF

“Fathered he is, and yet heโ€™s fatherless.”

  • Explanation: She acknowledges that her son has a father (Macduff) but, since Macduff has abandoned them, he is practically fatherless.
  • Analysis: This highlights her bitterness toward Macduffโ€™s decision to flee.
  • Language Device: Paradox โ€“ Her son has a father yet doesnโ€™t because Macduff is absent.

ROSS

**”I am so much a fool, should I stay longer

It would be my disgrace and your discomfort.”**

  • Explanation: Ross feels overwhelmed and fears that if he stays, he will either show too much emotion (making him look weak) or cause more distress for Lady Macduff.
  • Analysis: He is torn between loyalty to Macduff and sympathy for Lady Macduff.
  • Language Device: Juxtaposition (“disgrace and discomfort”) โ€“ Shows Rossโ€™s internal conflict.

“I take my leave at once.” (Ross exits.)

  • Explanation: Ross quickly leaves, possibly because he suspects danger or because he cannot bear Lady Macduffโ€™s pain and anger.

LADY MACDUFF

**”Sirrah, your fatherโ€™s dead.

https://wirelessbin.com/y9p8fv9cgu?key=325dca5266057209fa559a9743973653

And what will you do now? How will you live?”**

  • Explanation: She sarcastically tells her son that his father is as good as dead because he left them. She then asks how he will survive without a father.
  • Analysis: Her words show anger but also concern for her sonโ€™s future.
  • Language Device: Irony โ€“ She calls Macduff “dead,” but the real death is coming soon for them.

SON

“As birds do, mother.”

  • Explanation: The son says he will live like a bird, meaning he will find his own way to survive.
  • Analysis: This shows his innocence and resilience, but also foreshadows his vulnerability.
  • Language Device: Metaphor โ€“ He compares himself to a bird, symbolizing his fragility.

LADY MACDUFF

“What, with worms and flies?”

  • Explanation: She playfully mocks his response, asking if he will survive on scraps.
  • Analysis: This adds a moment of humor, making the tragedy that follows even more heartbreaking.

SON

“With what I get, I mean; and so do they.”

  • Explanation: He clarifies that birds survive with whatever they find, just as he will.
  • Analysis: This shows his innocent confidence, but also the harsh reality that he will not get the chance to grow up.

LADY MACDUFF

**”Poor bird, thou โ€™dst never fear the net nor lime,

The pitfall nor the gin.”**

  • Explanation: She says her son, like a naรฏve bird, doesnโ€™t fear traps, even though they exist.
  • Analysis: This foreshadows how her son is unaware of the danger approaching.
  • Language Device: Metaphor โ€“ “Net, lime, pitfall, and gin” represent traps set by evil people (like Macbethโ€™s men).

SON

“Why should I, mother? Poor birds they are not set for.”

  • Explanation: He believes that hunters donโ€™t bother trapping poor, weak birds like him.
  • Analysis: This is tragically ironic because the murderers do come for him, despite his innocence.
  • Language Device: Dramatic Irony โ€“ The audience knows he is wrong, making his fate even sadder.

LADY MACDUFF

“My father is not dead, for all your saying.”

  • Explanation: The son insists that Macduff is still alive, even though his mother keeps calling him dead.
  • Analysis: This shows the sonโ€™s faith in his father, contrasting with Lady Macduffโ€™s anger and betrayal.

LADY MACDUFF

“Yes, he is dead. How wilt thou do for a father?”

  • Explanation: She insists that Macduff is “dead” to them, asking how her son will manage without a father.
  • Analysis: This highlights her bitterness and fear about being left alone.

SON

“Nay, how will you do for a husband?”

  • Explanation: The son cleverly turns the question back on her, asking how she will survive without a husband.
  • Analysis: This moment of childish wit adds humor but also reflects his maturity beyond his years.

LADY MACDUFF

“Why, I can buy me twenty at any market.”

  • Explanation: She sarcastically suggests that men are easily replaceable, unlike a father to a child.
  • Analysis: This reflects her anger toward Macduff, but also her understanding that a fatherโ€™s role is irreplaceable.
  • Language Device: Hyperbole โ€“ Exaggerating that she could “buy” twenty husbands emphasizes her frustration.

SON

“Then youโ€™ll buy โ€™em to sell again.”

  • Explanation: The son jokes that if she can buy husbands, she might sell them too, implying that marriage isnโ€™t as simple as trade.
  • Analysis: His wit contrasts with his tragic fate, making his upcoming death even more heartbreaking.

LADY MACDUFF

**”Thou speakโ€™st with all thy wit,

And yet, iโ€™ faith, with wit enough for thee.”**

  • Explanation: She praises her son for his cleverness, but suggests that he still has much to learn.
  • Analysis: This is a tender moment between mother and son, making the impending tragedy even more painful.

SON

“Was my father a traitor, mother?”

  • Explanation: The son asks directly if Macduff was a traitor.
  • Analysis: His question shows that even a child is aware of political accusations, reflecting the corrupt world they live in.

LADY MACDUFF

“Ay, that he was.”

  • Explanation: She sarcastically agrees, though she doesnโ€™t truly believe it.
  • Analysis: This shows her anger but also highlights how false accusations spread quickly in Macbethโ€™s reign.

SON

“What is a traitor?”

  • Explanation: He asks for a definition, showing his innocence and curiosity.

LADY MACDUFF

“Why, one that swears and lies.”

  • Explanation: She gives a simple answer, saying that traitors are people who make promises but break them.
  • Analysis: She is unknowingly describing Macbeth, not Macduff.
  • Language Device: Irony โ€“ Macbeth is the real traitor, not Macduff.

SON

“And be all traitors that do so?”

  • Explanation: He asks if every liar is a traitor, showing childlike logic.

LADY MACDUFF

“Every one that does so is a traitor and must be hanged.”

  • Explanation: She says all liars deserve death, unknowingly foreshadowing her own fate.
  • Language Device: Foreshadowing โ€“ Lady Macduff and her son will soon be murdered by Macbethโ€™s orders.

LADY MACDUFF:

“Every one.”

  • Lady Macduff responds simply and firmly to her son’s question about whether all liars and swearers should be hanged.
  • Her short, blunt answer emphasizes her belief in justice and morality.
  • This line contrasts with the corruption in Macbethโ€™s world, where dishonesty thrives.

SON:

“Who must hang them?”

  • The son, with childlike innocence, questions who will enforce justice.
  • This is ironic, as he points out a flaw in his mother’s logicโ€”who will punish the guilty if they are the majority?
  • His curiosity reflects a deeper theme of power and corruption, where justice is weak.

LADY MACDUFF:

“Why, the honest men.”

  • Lady Macduff insists that good people will uphold justice.
  • However, in the world of Macbeth, honesty is often punished, and evil is rewarded.
  • This statement is dramatic irony because the audience knows that Scotland is ruled by a corrupt king.

SON:

“Then the liars and swearers are fools, for there are liars and swearers enough to beat the honest men and hang up them.”

  • The son makes a sharp observation: if dishonest people outnumber honest ones, they could take control.
  • This line is filled with irony and dark humorโ€”the child understands the world’s corruption better than his mother.
  • It reflects the reversal of justice in Macbeth, where the wicked are in power.
  • Themes: Corruption, Injustice, Power Dynamics

LADY MACDUFF:

“Now God help thee, poor monkey!”

  • Lady Macduff affectionately calls her son a โ€œpoor monkey,โ€ which is a term of endearment.
  • However, there is an underlying melancholy, as she recognizes that her son is powerless in a world ruled by cruelty.
  • Foreshadowing: This line hints at the tragic fate awaiting her and her son.

LADY MACDUFF:

“But how wilt thou do for a father?”

  • She abruptly shifts the conversation to Macduffโ€™s absence, showing her bitterness and frustration.
  • The question carries emotional weightโ€”she is both concerned for her son and angry at her husband.
  • Themes: Family, Betrayal, Abandonment

SON:

“If he were dead, youโ€™d weep for him. If you would not, it were a good sign that I should quickly have a new father.”

  • The son logically assumes that if Macduff were dead, his mother would be mourning. Since she is not, he believes Macduff is alive.
  • His second statement is darkly humorousโ€”he implies that if Macduff were truly gone, she would remarry.
  • Foreshadowing: This line hints at Lady Macduffโ€™s future vulnerability.

LADY MACDUFF:

“Poor prattler, how thou talkโ€™st!”

  • “Prattler” means someone who talks too much. Lady Macduff lovingly teases her son for speaking beyond his years.
  • This moment of tenderness between mother and son contrasts with the violence that follows.
  • Themes: Innocence, Family, Love

Enter a Messenger.

  • The arrival of the messenger shifts the tone from warmth to tension and urgency.
  • The contrast between the playful dialogue and the impending danger builds suspense.

MESSENGER:

“Bless you, fair dame. I am not to you known,
Though in your state of honor I am perfect.”

  • The messenger is a stranger, yet he recognizes Lady Macduffโ€™s noble status.
  • His greeting is respectful, showing that even in a corrupt world, some still value morality.
  • Themes: Honor, Loyalty

MESSENGER:

“I doubt some danger does approach you nearly.”

  • “Doubt” here means “fear” or “suspect.” He warns Lady Macduff that she is in immediate danger.
  • The phrasing heightens suspense, making it clear that something terrible is about to happen.
  • Themes: Fate, Danger

MESSENGER:

“If you will take a homely manโ€™s advice,
Be not found here. Hence with your little ones!”

  • The messenger, a simple man, advises her to flee immediately.
  • “Homely” suggests he is of low status, yet he is more aware of danger than Lady Macduff.
  • His warning is a moment of dramatic tensionโ€”will she escape in time?

MESSENGER:

“To fright you thus methinks I am too savage;
To do worse to you were fell cruelty,
Which is too nigh your person. Heaven preserve you!”

  • He apologizes for scaring her but knows that a greater horror is coming.
  • “Fell cruelty” means extreme violenceโ€”he suggests that something terrible is about to happen.
  • Religious imagery: “Heaven preserve you!” reflects his helplessnessโ€”only divine intervention can save her now.
  • Themes: Fate, Fear, Helplessness

MESSENGER:

“I dare abide no longer.”

  • The messenger quickly leaves, showing that he himself is afraid.
  • His departure increases the sense of impending doom.

LADY MACDUFF:

“Whither should I fly?”

  • She questions where she can go, feeling trapped.
  • This reflects her helplessnessโ€”she has done nothing wrong, yet she is the one in danger.

LADY MACDUFF:

“I have done no harm. But I remember now
I am in this earthly world, where to do harm
Is often laudable, to do good sometime
Accounted dangerous folly.”

  • Lady Macduff reflects on the injustice of the world.
  • “To do harm is often laudable”โ€”evil is praised in this world.
  • “To do good… dangerous folly”โ€”being good can lead to punishment.
  • This is situational ironyโ€”she is innocent, yet she is about to be killed.
  • Themes: Corruption, Injustice, Fate

LADY MACDUFF:

“Why then, alas,
Do I put up that womanly defense
To say I have done no harm?”

  • She realizes that protesting her innocence is pointless.
  • “Womanly defense” suggests that she sees her plea as weak, yet she has no other option.
  • The tragic irony is that her goodness will not save her.

Enter Murderers.

  • The stage direction signals immediate danger.
  • Their entrance interrupts her reflection, emphasizing how quickly fate turns against her.

LADY MACDUFF:

“What are these faces?”

  • Her question shows shock and fearโ€”she doesnโ€™t even recognize them as people, just as “faces” of death.
  • Themes: Fear, Fate, Injustice

MURDERER:

“Where is your husband?”

  • The murderer doesnโ€™t kill her immediatelyโ€”he first demands to know about Macduff.
  • This shows Macbethโ€™s paranoiaโ€”he wants revenge on Macduff and his family.
  • The question also adds psychological cruelty, making her think about her husbandโ€™s absence in her final moments.

LADY MACDUFF:

“I hope in no place so unsanctified
Where such as thou mayst find him.”

Explanation:

  • Lady Macduff responds to the murdererโ€™s demand to know where her husband is.
  • She denies knowing where Macduff is but also implies that he is not in a place that is “unsanctified” (unholy or wicked).
  • Her words carry a double meaning:
    • She is expressing hope that Macduff is far from evil men like the murderer.
    • She is subtly insulting the murderer, suggesting that he is an unholy person who can only exist in sinful places.
  • The line shows Lady Macduffโ€™s courageโ€”she refuses to betray her husband, even in the face of death.

Language Devices:

  • Religious imagery: The word “unsanctified” contrasts purity with corruption, reinforcing the theme of good vs. evil.
  • Dramatic irony: The audience knows that Macduff has gone to England to seek help against Macbeth, but Lady Macduff is unaware.

Themes:

  • Loyalty and Betrayal โ€“ Lady Macduff remains loyal to her husband, even though she feels abandoned.
  • Good vs. Evil โ€“ She represents goodness, while the murderers represent the corruption under Macbethโ€™s rule.

MURDERER:

“Heโ€™s a traitor.”

Explanation:

  • The murderer falsely accuses Macduff of being a traitor.
  • This is Macbethโ€™s propagandaโ€”Macduff is branded a traitor simply because he opposes Macbeth.
  • The line is bitterly ironic:
    • The real traitor is Macbeth, who has betrayed Scotland by killing Duncan and seizing power.
    • Macduff, in reality, is a hero trying to save the country.

Language Devices:

  • Irony: The audience knows Macduff is not a traitor, making this accusation unjust and hypocritical.
  • Bluntness: The short sentence emphasizes how easily words like “traitor” are used as weapons in Macbethโ€™s Scotland.

Themes:

  • Corruption of Power โ€“ Macbethโ€™s rule distorts justice, labeling good men as criminals.
  • Loyalty vs. Treason โ€“ The definition of “traitor” is twisted under Macbethโ€™s tyranny.

SON:

“Thou liest, thou shag-eared villain!”

Explanation:

  • The young boy bravely defends his father, immediately calling the murderer a liar.
  • His insult, โ€œshag-eared villain,โ€ shows his defiance despite being just a child.
  • His reaction is heartbreakingโ€”he is too young to understand the danger he is in.

Language Devices:

  • Direct Insult (“shag-eared villain”): A childish but bold way to show defiance.
  • Irony: His bravery is admirable, but it tragically leads to his death.

Themes:

  • Innocence vs. Brutality โ€“ The boy represents purity, while the murderer represents merciless violence.
  • Fate and Destiny โ€“ His death seems inevitable in Macbethโ€™s corrupt world.

MURDERER:

“What, you egg?”
(Stabbing him.)
“Young fry of treachery!”

Explanation:

  • The murderer calls the boy an โ€œegg,โ€ meaning he is young and defenseless.
  • “Young fry of treachery” suggests that, as Macduffโ€™s son, he will grow up to be a traitor (even though Macduff is not actually a traitor).
  • The murderer dehumanizes the boy, seeing him as an extension of Macduff rather than an innocent child.

Language Devices:

  • Metaphor (“egg”): Suggests vulnerability, innocence, and potential.
  • Symbolism: Eggs symbolize new life, making the murder even more horrific.
  • Irony: The child is accused of “treachery” when he is completely innocent.

Themes:

  • Violence and Tyranny โ€“ Macbethโ€™s rule is so brutal that even children are not spared.
  • Fate and Predestination โ€“ The murderer assumes the son will grow up to be his fatherโ€™s heir, justifying his murder.

SON:

“He has killed me, mother.”

Explanation:

  • The sonโ€™s final words are tragically simple.
  • His recognition of death contrasts with his earlier playfulness, making the moment more painful.
  • His innocence is further highlightedโ€”he doesnโ€™t cry out for revenge, just acknowledges the truth.

Language Devices:

  • Direct, childlike speech: His last words are not poetic or dramatic, making them feel even more real and heart-wrenching.
  • Irony: He is too young to understand what is happening, yet he faces death with acceptance.

Themes:

  • Innocence Destroyed โ€“ The childโ€™s death symbolizes the complete collapse of morality in Macbethโ€™s world.
  • The Horrors of Tyranny โ€“ Macbethโ€™s rule extends its cruelty to innocent children.

SON:

“Run away, I pray you.”

Explanation:

  • With his dying breath, the son tells his mother to flee.
  • His concern for her safety, even as he dies, highlights his selflessness.
  • Bitter irony: Lady Macduff cannot escape her fate eitherโ€”she will be killed soon after.

Language Devices:

  • Imperative (“Run away”): Urges urgency, but it is ultimately futile.
  • Irony: He tells his mother to escape, yet the audience knows she is doomed.

Themes:

  • Family and Sacrifice โ€“ The boy tries to save his mother, despite being the one who is dying.
  • Fate and Inescapability โ€“ Even with a warning, Lady Macduff cannot outrun her fate.

Stage Direction:

Lady Macduff exits, crying “Murder!” followed by the Murderers bearing the Sonโ€™s body.

Explanation:

  • Lady Macduffโ€™s cry of “Murder!” is a final moment of resistanceโ€”she refuses to die in silence.
  • The murderers carrying the sonโ€™s body away is an image of absolute horror.
  • Theatrical Impact: This scene would be shocking to an audience, reinforcing the brutality of Macbethโ€™s rule.

Themes:

  • The Collapse of Order โ€“ Macbethโ€™s Scotland is a place where even women and children are slaughtered.
  • Injustice and Tyranny โ€“ The strong prey upon the weak, with no one left to stop them.

Tags:

Leave a Reply

Discover more from The Educator Online

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading