128,882 hits

Macbeth Act 5 Scene 4 Line-by-Line Explanation

SIWARD

โ€œWe learn no other but the confident tyrant / Keeps still in Dunsinane and will endure / Our setting down before โ€™t.โ€

  • Meaning: All reports say Macbeth, the overly confident tyrant, remains in his castle at Dunsinane and is prepared to endure a siege from us.
  • Analysis: Siward refers to Macbeth as a “confident tyrant,” which highlights how Macbeth still believes he is invincible, probably because of the witchesโ€™ prophecies. Siward sounds almost surprised that Macbeth isnโ€™t fleeing or engagingโ€”heโ€™s just waiting, stubbornly relying on hope rather than strategy.
  • Language device:
    • Epithets: “Confident tyrant” is a loaded phrase, combining Macbethโ€™s arrogance with his abuse of power.
    • Irony: The audience knows Macbethโ€™s confidence is based on misinterpreted prophecies, not real strength.
  • Themes:
    • Hubris and downfall: Macbethโ€™s belief in his invulnerability is pushing him to make fatal decisions.
    • Leadership: Contrast between Malcolmโ€™s strategic thinking and Macbethโ€™s prideful inaction.

MALCOLM

โ€œโ€™Tis his main hope; / For, where there is advantage to be given, / Both more and less have given him the revolt,โ€

  • Meaning: This is Macbethโ€™s only real hope nowโ€”staying in the castle. Because if there were any opportunity for others to leave him, both the high-ranking and low-ranking people have already abandoned him.
  • Analysis: Malcolm recognizes that Macbeth is isolated. His support has withered away except for those who are either forced or afraid to leave.
  • Language device:
    • Antithesis: โ€œBoth more and lessโ€ = nobles and commoners alike.
  • Themes:
    • Tyranny isolates: Even though Macbeth holds the throne, he has lost loyalty.
    • Rebellion and justice: The rightful forces are gathering strength while Macbeth loses allies.

โ€œAnd none serve with him but constrained things / Whose hearts are absent too.โ€

  • Meaning: The only people still with Macbeth are doing so unwillingly. Their bodies may be there, but their hearts and loyalty are not.
  • Analysis: Suggests that Macbethโ€™s army is weak in spiritโ€”those who remain are not inspired or motivated.
  • Language device:
    • Metaphor: โ€œConstrained thingsโ€ โ€“ people reduced to objects, forced into service.
  • Themes:
    • Loyalty vs. coercion: Macbeth has ruled by fear, not respect.
    • Leadership and morale: Contrasts with the unity in Malcolmโ€™s army.

MACDUFF

โ€œLet our just censures / Attend the true event, and put we on / Industrious soldiership.โ€

  • Meaning: Letโ€™s wait for the real outcome before judging things, and meanwhile, letโ€™s act as disciplined and hard-working soldiers.
  • Analysis: Macduff is a practical and focused warrior. He suggests it’s too early to celebrate or criticizeโ€”they must focus on fighting.
  • Language device:
    • Alliteration: โ€œjust censuresโ€ emphasizes fair judgment.
  • Themes:
    • Duty and honor: Soldiers should focus on action, not assumptions.
    • Justice: The idea of letting truth unfold before passing judgment.

SIWARD

โ€œThe time approaches / That will with due decision make us know / What we shall say we have and what we owe.โ€

  • Meaning: The moment is coming that will decide everythingโ€”what weโ€™ll gain and what it has cost us.
  • Analysis: Siward reflects on warโ€™s uncertaintiesโ€”victory comes with sacrifice.
  • Themes:
    • Reality of war: Not just about glory, but also about what is lost.
    • Honor and sacrifice: War demands a reckoning with cost.

โ€œThoughts speculative their unsure hopes relate, / But certain issue strokes must arbitrate;โ€

  • Meaning: Speculative thoughts are based on uncertain hopes, but only real actions and outcomes will settle things.
  • Analysis: You can hope and imagine all you want, but the final decision lies in the battle.
  • Language device:
    • Personification: โ€œStrokesโ€ (sword strikes) are the real decision-makers.
  • Themes:
    • Action vs. words: Action will determine truth, not speculation.
    • Fate and free will: Despite prophecy, they must still fight for the result.

MALCOLM

โ€œTowards which, advance the war.โ€

  • Meaning: Letโ€™s move forward to battle!
  • Analysis: Strong and decisive leadership from Malcolm.
  • Theme: Justice and restoration. The rightful heir is now taking direct action.

They exit marching.

  • Symbolism: The march represents destiny moving forward. The prophecy is about to be fulfilled, and Macbethโ€™s downfall is imminent.

Tags:

Leave a Reply

Discover more from The Educator Online

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading